Doula or Dont’cha?

by Deborah Cruz on June 13, 2012

Post image for Doula or Dont’cha?

I have never really understood what the difference is between a doula and a midwife. I’ve decided, after birthing two children, it was time that I figure it out.

One of my really good friends is a doula and I know that she is awesome but I’m not exactly sure what she actually does. It’s one of those cases where we’ve been friends for so long now that if I asked her to explain what she actually does it would be almost as insulting and offensive as asking what her husband’s name is.

Yes, I know his name, in case you were wondering.

Doula:

A woman experienced in childbirth who provides advice, information, emotional support, and physical comfort to a mother before, during, and just after childbirth.

Hold the phone! She’s been holding out on me. I could have used her at both of my births. Serves me right for not knowing what she does for a living.

Nurse-Midwife:

A registered nurse with additional training as a midwife who is certified to deliver infants and provide prenatal and postpartum care, newborn care, and some routine care (as gynecological exams) of women.

If I understand correctly, a doula is a woman who has actually given birth and provides the laboring mother with support before, during and after giving birth. A nurse-midwife is a medically trained nurse who is certified to deliver babies and can be of medical assistance throughout your pregnancy and during your postpartum time period.

Both sound like good ideas.

If I had to choose though I would go with the doula for the same reason that I normally only see female obstetricians and gynecologists; I want someone who understands what it feels like to go through having their feet in the stirrups.

I just feel like there is an added measure of understanding and sympathy given and perhaps even quality of care by someone who has actually been through the experience of childbirth themselves – firsthand.

Did you have a doula or a midwife? What was the deciding factor?

Photo Source: GregoryRAllen

Be Sociable, Share!
  • Julie C.

    Neither, but I can tell you — I ‘ve had a male doctor and a female doctor deliver my babies and the experience with the female doctor was by FAR more pleasant, supportive and comforting than with the very qualified, experienced male doctor. Maybe it was just me, but females and giving birth just naturally go together!

  • http://www.centraljerseyworkingmoms.com/ CC Fowler

    I wish I knew of Doulas back when I was pregnant.  It would have made for a much easier transition after my babies were born.  In all fairness, my Hubby was really terrific with both pregnancies and births but after, I did feel anxious.  I forwarded this post to my firend who is expecting soon.  Great info!

  • Astoria_lily

    I had 2 doulas-one for birth, and a different one for after I brough the newborn home. I was a first-time mom, my own mom had passed away, no sister, no M-I-L, and I knew my child’s father was not going to be helpful in either phase of having my child. I knew I needed someone to help me,  so after looking at the price ranges to see if I could afford it, I decided to hire someone. It was the best decision I could have made! My birthing doula (with 3 kids of her own) helped me prepare for the birth by practing pain-reducing techniques, was with me almost every moment of my 42 hr labor, brough food in on the sly so I wasn’t starved, communicated with the drs and nurses when I was too exhausted, was the one who made them understand that I finally did want that epidural at hr 36, (and told them when it didn’t work properly), made them send for the dr at hr 41 when she could see the baby wasn’t going to progress any farther, and sent the father somewhere else when I was ready to kill him. She also was the one who took the first photos of me with my child after my surgery. My post-partum doula taught me how to swaddle, breastfeed, give my baby a bath, walked me though a bedtime routine, and brought baby gear- like slings- for me to try and then returned the rest to the store, so I didn’t have to make the trip post-surgery. Both women were amazing and I am so glad I invested in their expertise. The only thing in the article I would correct is that a doula is not always a mother first. My 2nd one wasn’t (although she has 2 of her own now!) but still was exactly what I needed.

Previous post:

Next post: