Do You Make These Discipline Mistakes?

Posted on Nov 2, 2012 by 1 Comment
Do You Make These Discipline Mistakes?

Have you ever noticed how many instruction manuals come with a new car, a new stove, or even your new flat iron? Now, have you noticed that you don’t get the same number of manuals with your children?

It is totally wrong. I could work a stove in my sleep, but having a few more manufacturers’ instructions for raising my kids would be awesome.

Discipline is one of the most difficult things to get down. How do you find the balance between healthy discipline that will teach your child to be a responsible, functioning part of society and turning them into a sociopath?

It’s hard.

The thing is, you’ll be able to see the mistakes other parents make once your kids are grown up, but it is hard to listen to more experienced parents’ advice when you are in the midst of child rearing. It just doesn’t seem like they understand your unique situation.

Believe me, we understand.

So, from the perspective of a very experienced parent, let me share some of my thoughts. Feel free to take them or leave them. Four of my eight kids are responsible adults and the rest are on their way. Not a sociopath in the bunch – yet.

Know When to Discipline

Children go through stages as they grow. They have different levels of physical, emotional, and intellectual development and there is no point in disciplining for something they can’t help. For example, kids under the age of five spill things. They just do.

Eventually they grow out of it (mostly), but yelling at your four year old for spilling a glass of milk or bowl of spaghetti is pointless. You are reacting from anger and frustration. Same thing with a tantrum – don’t encourage it but don’t discipline for it either. Just walk away.

A ten year old will eventually know her multiplication tables. There is no point in grounding her for not being able to memorize them unless she is totally blowing off school all together.

Teenagers are going to experiment and try things you’d rather they wouldn’t. Sometimes you need to discipline but often the consequences of their bad choices will often be enough.

Timing Is Everything

Having one parent be the primary disciplinarian creates family factions. The disciplining parent becomes the mean one while the non-disciplining parent is labeled as the fun one. It encourages kids to play one against the other and creates discord.

Don’t wait until the other parent gets home to administer correction, handle the situation immediately.

Say What You Mean

How many times have you heard a parent say, “Junior! If you do that again you will get a time out!” Now, how many times have you heard a parent say that phrase three or more times before acting on the threat?

When you make a discipline statement you need to follow up on it immediately. Counting, repeating your statement, or ignoring the behavior just teaches your child that he has the option of continuing in his behavior until he senses you are about to get mad and follow through.

There are times when you threaten something and then for a very good reason don’t go through with it, but these times should be rare.

Don’t Get Mad

When your child is doing something wrong it is easy to ignore it until you get angry. Disciplining when you are frustrated and angry is not discipline – it’s retaliation. When a child knowingly breaks a rule you discipline. Period.

Discipline for the Right Things

This goes along with the first point. Don’t discipline for honest mistakes but only for intentional breaking of rules.

If a child accidentally breaks a lamp, then having him clean it up and asking him to be more careful in the future should be sufficient. It could happen to anyone.

If a child breaks a lamp because he is throwing a football in the house, knowing that that is not appropriate? Well folks, that is begging for discipline.

Do you agree or disagree?

photo credit: Christine Szeto

Posted in: Parenting
Marye Audet

Marye Audet is an author, freelance writer, and editor. As a work at home mom she has a unique perspective that encompasses the overwhelming deadlines and commitments of the professional woman as well as the constantly changing needs of a homeschooling mom with a large family. She is the author of one cook book and the creator of Restless Chipotle Media, a network consisting of two food based blogs, a blog for “women of a certain age”, a video site on Youtube, and upcoming blog on kitchen decor, and downloadable eBooks. Marye also is a freelance writer, editor, and book reviewer.

Read more posts by


  • Emily (CityBaby Living)

    Ugh, it’s so hard! Just when I feel like I have a handle on it, my daughter grows into a new stage. It’s also the only parenting task my husband and I disagree on – not profoundly, but he wants to make unilateral rules that I feel don’t always apply to our 5yo. Man I wish there was a manual! Thanks for the advice.